The Relationship between Fundamental and Technical Analysis

27 September 2020 By PDSNET

There are generally two approaches to share assessment – fundamental and technical analysis. The fundamentalist is trying to answer the question, “How good will the company be as a generator of dividends in the future?” while the technician is looking for patterns in the share’s price and volume charts to improve his predictions of where the share price will go next. Both approaches have their merits and they are linked together.

Fundamental analysis strives to forecast the future dividends of a share and then discount them into today’s money. That discounted value can then compared to the share’s price in the market to determine whether it is cheap or expensive. Consciously or subconsciously, every investor adjusts his perceptions of the current value of a share based on the company’s potential for generating future profits and hence dividends.

For example, suppose you are considering buying a gold share which is trading in the market for R10 on Friday – and then the gold price drops by $50 an ounce over the weekend. Will you still be willing to pay R10 for it on Monday? Certainly not. You and all the investors who are considering this share will automatically adjust their perceptions of its value downwards because its future potential profitability has been reduced. While you may not have constructed a specific forecast of future dividends and then reduced that to a current value, you have intuitively discounted its potential into a lower present value – and so has everyone else.

In fact, if you can make a capital gain on a share then it is because the person who buys it from you has a higher perception of the value of its future dividends than you had when you bought it. A capital gain is just the dividend in a different form. It comes about because of a shift in group perceptions of the future dividend flow. The market price of a share, at any moment in time, is the average of all investors’ conscious or sub-conscious discounted cash flows of the future dividends of that company.

Let us imagine for a moment that you have a time machine and you can travel forward into the future. By doing that, you establish that your forecast of the future dividends of the company is 100% correct. You then return to today’s time and you see all the other investors desperately trying to predict that future flow of dividends – but you now know the truth. You know exactly what the future dividends will be – and that enables you to accurately calculate the share’s real value.

With that thought in your head, we can define fundamental analysis as the search for the share’s real value and technical analysis as the study of investors’ perceptions of the real value – as it is reflected in the share’s price and volume pattern. In other words, there are two types of investors out there. There are conservative people like stockbrokers and institutional fund managers who say that they will not buy a share unless they can see the real value – and then there are others who say the real value does not matter. What matters is what people think the real value is. There is the reality and the perception of the reality – and obviously those two are inter-related because changes in the fundamental facts about a share will impact on investors’ perceptions of it.

This understanding is a framework onto which you can hang everything which you learn, both fundamental and technical, about the share market.


All information and data contained within the PDSnet Articles is for informational purposes only. PDSnet makes no representations as to the accuracy, completeness, suitability, or validity, of any information, and shall not be liable for any errors, omissions, or any losses, injuries, or damages arising from its display or use. Information in the PDSnet Articles are based on the author’s opinion and experience and should not be considered professional financial investment advice. The ideas and strategies should never be used without first assessing your own personal and financial situation, or without consulting a financial professional. Thoughts and opinions will also change from time to time as more information is accumulated. PDSnet reserves the right to delete any comment or opinion for any reason.

Share this article:


Elimination of the Bears

As far back as January 2016, billionaire George Soros went short on the S&P500 index. This means that he thought the S&P500 was going to fall heavily and he took positions which would profit from a major fall in that index. Later in May 2017 he doubled up on those “short” positions and he has been taking more short positions ever since. As recently as final quarter of 2020 he bought


Truworths (TRU) is a retailer of fashionware in South Africa and the UK. As such its business has been damaged by the impact of Brexit in the UK and the recessionary conditions in the South African economy. Both countries have then been impacted by lockdowns which prevented in-store sales for a period of time, beginning in late March 2020. The second wave of the pandemic has also been a factor. In the UK,

The Coming Blow-off

At the start of 2021, it is as well to stand back and consider the context of where world markets are as they slavishly follow Wall Street up to new record highs.  Consider the 12-year chart of the S&P500:

The chart shows that the great bull market which began in March 2009 is on-going. It is moving within a clearly defined channel.

Window Dressing

We all know that our market, the JSE, is dominated by the big institutions – the pension funds, unit trusts, insurance companies and a scattering of large fund managers. These institutions together account for at least 90% of the trades on the JSE by value. We private investors make up the rest.
Big institutions have huge holdings of mostly blue-chip or

The Rand Bull

For some years now we have believed that the rand was underpriced in relation to the currencies of first world countries, especially the US dollar. We have also said that the rand, as one of the most heavily traded emerging market currencies, is a barometer of the international investment community’s perception of risk in the world economy. When investors

Start an Investment Club

A few years ago, we developed software to manage an in-house investment club for our staff members. We now offer it to any member of the public who wants to set up an investment club, free of charge. Using the daily closing prices from the JSE, this software is designed to keep track of the investments of a group of people who have decided to work together on investing directly

The Confidential Report - December 2020

We have come to the end of a tumultuous and unique year marked by the “black swan” event of COVID-19, various Trump excesses and, finally, his vanquishing. The long-term progress of the S&P500 as outlined in “our Background Approach” on our web site remains in tact. In that scenario, the world economy is moving into a strong boom phase stimulated by unprecedented


Property shares on the JSE have had a torrid time over the last few years. It began with the melt-down which resulted from the Resilient crisis, now substantially behind us, and continued with the eventual failure of the Edcon Group and the effects of the COVID-19 lockdown. These events have combined with a generally negative economy to reduce the value of property shares significantly.

Market Overview

Now that the uncertainty of the US election is essentially over, it is perhaps a good time to step back and consider where we are and what is likely to happen next.

The S&P500 index, which is an excellent benchmark for trends in the international markets, appears to be breaking to a new record high – above the resistance at 3580. Consider the chart: