ARTICLES

Sibanye Vs Amplats

Right now, comparing Amplats with Sibanye is instructive for private investors – and made more interesting because:

1. They are both mining houses producing precious metals, mainly platinum group metals.(PGM's).
2. They have the same financial year-end (31^st December).
3. They have both recently produced trading statements for the 2020 financial year ending on 31^st December 2020.
4. They both expect to have generated about R30bn of headline earnings in that year.

It seems reasonable for these two companies in more-or-less the same business which produce about the same profit to have about the same value in the market – but they don’t. Investors see Amplats as being worth more than twice as much as Sibanye – yet they are producing about the same profits in roughly the same business.

The market capitalisation of Amplats (R442,6bn) is 2,3 times as high as that of Sibanye (R188bn). In other words, Amplats is owned 77,28% by Anglo American and it has a long track record of being a very professionally managed, blue chip mining house focused on the production of PGM's. In recent years it has moved decisively away from the complexity and cost of deep level mining towards shallower, more mechanized operations.

Sibanye has relatively recently been cobbled together by mining expert Neal Froneman, over the past 8 years, through a series of daring and brilliant acquisitions. For half of that time (until January 2016) precious metals prices were under pressure. Then the commodity cycle turned, and prices began rising.

Froneman has always been very positive about the future of precious metals and has bought up anything which was being sold for a bargain price – including some of the operations that were sold off by Amplats. He is most notable for his acquisitions of:

1. The Stillwater palladium mine in America
2. Lonmin after the Marikana massacre

The Stillwater acquisition loaded Sibanye’s balance sheet with debt, but it gave the company a first world palladium mine and diversified it away from its exposure to South Africa. Lonmin was bought for Sibanye shares at a very good price and came with a valuable extraction plant. It was, however, purchased when the company was on the brink of collapse.

Today, the price:earnings (P:E) multiple of Sibanye is 31,37 while that of Amplats is 24,44. On the face of it, this means that Sibanye is slightly more “highly rated” by investors than Amplats, but it is important to understand that these multiples are based on historical earnings. If we use the projected earnings of the two companies for the year ending 31^st December 2020, then the forward multiple for Amplats is between 13,93 and 15,74 while that of Sibanye is between 5,95 and 6,19.

That shows that investors are prepared to pay more than twice as much for 100c of earnings from Amplats as they are for 100c of earnings from Sibanye. The reasons for this are inter alia:

• Amplats has a much longer history of good management and profitability than Sibanye – which reduces the risk.
• Sibanye includes some gold assets while Amplats is a pure PGM play.
• Amplats produced almost 75% more PGM ounces than Sibanye, but Sibanye produced over 25 000 kilograms of gold as well.
• In the 2019 year, Sibanye generated R62m in profits while Amplats generated R18bn – so investors see Sibanye’s 2020 profits as less sustainable.
• Overall, Amplats is seen as much more stable and reliable, while Sibanye has the wild card advantage of Froneman’s evident brilliance.

Sibanye has about 2,9bn shares in issue trading at R64.84 while Amplats has 265,3m shares in issue at a price of R1668.37. So, Sibanye has about 11 times more shares in issue – mainly because of the various acquisitions which it has made for shares.

The final point to make about these two shares is their relative performance. Consider the chart of their comparative relative strength:

You can see here that once the commodity cycle turned, Amplats was out-performing Sibanye by a wide margin. This was mainly because of its well-established infrastructure and good name. From about July 2019, however, Sibanye began to outperform Amplats as investors realised that Froneman’s gambles had paid off and the company was going to benefit from the strong rise in PGM prices.

Commodity shares like Sibanye and Amplats are always more volatile and risky because they are dependent on the prices of internationally traded commodities. A well-established mining house like Amplats is always going to be far less risky than a company like Sibanye which owes much of its success to one man’s brilliance.

DISCLAIMER

All information and data contained within the PDSnet Articles is for informational purposes only. PDSnet makes no representations as to the accuracy, completeness, suitability, or validity, of any information, and shall not be liable for any errors, omissions, or any losses, injuries, or damages arising from its display or use. Information in the PDSnet Articles are based on the author’s opinion and experience and should not be considered professional financial investment advice. The ideas and strategies should never be used without first assessing your own personal and financial situation, or without consulting a financial professional. Thoughts and opinions will also change from time to time as more information is accumulated. PDSnet reserves the right to delete any comment or opinion for any reason.

PDSNET ARTICLES

Shoprite

In their article on 10^th April 2024, Checkers sweeps Pick n Pay as it opens 5 new stores in one day., Businesstech drew attention to the fact that Shoprite had taken over five stores from Pick ‘n Pay on the East Rand. Pick

WeBuyCars

In a few days’ time, Transaction Capital (TCP) will unbundle and separately list its second-hand car sales company, WeBuyCars (WBC). The main benefit of this is to release the value of WBC into the hands of its shareholders. When the listing is complete, on 11^th April 2024, WBC will have a total of 417,2m shares in issue which are expected to

Gold and Harmony

In our last Confidential Report, published on 6^th March 2024, we drew your attention to the fact that the US dollar price of gold was about to break up through a critical resistance level at $2060. Gold has now moved up to $2166 so this observation provided an opportunity for private investors to make a significant capital gain, either in actual gold

Reverse Takeover

At the end of October 2023, Mix Telematics (MIX) was a relatively small fleet management company with a market capitalisation of just R2,3bn listed on both the JSE and the American NASDAQ. Its shares on the JSE were wallowing at a low of 380c. This compares with its competitor, Karoo (KRO), also listed on the JSE, but which was at the time, more

Rare Opportunity

You may not have been aware of it, but last week, between Monday and Friday, there was an opportunity to make an 80% profit on your capital. This opportunity occurred because of insider trading on a little known and traded share called Quantum Foods (QFH) in the poultry and animal feeds business.

Generally, the poultry business is

Excessive Bullishness

On Friday last week, the S&P500 index posted yet another new record closing high, but this time just one point higher than the previous day at 5088. This means that the index, which measures the progress of the 500 largest companies on Wall Street, has been climbing without a significant correction for nearly four months. Consider the chart:

Lessons from Transcap

As a private investor it is very important that you study what has happened in the past and learn from it. The progress of Transaction Capital (TCP) has provided us with an excellent opportunity to examine and learn from a complete cycle in an institutional favourite share. We can examine the entire cycle and see how to profit from it. In this regard, it is important

Sasol

Sasol is a company originally established in September 1950 by the National Party, to counter the possibility of petrochemical sanctions against the old South Africa. Essentially, Sasol used South Africa’s enormous coal reserves to generate about one third of its fuel requirements. Subsequently, Sasol became involved in the chemical industry which now accounts for about

4Sight

The world has, in the last twenty years, entered what has been characterised as the 4^th Industrial Revolution (4IR). It has been described as “... the biggest structural change of the past 250 years — a transformation of scale, scope and complexity unlike anything humankind has experienced before.” In simpler terms, 4IR refers to the digital convergence of

The Great Bull Resumes

On the 12th of June 2023, we published an article, headed "Bull Trend?". In that article we suggested that, after a 25% correction, the great bull market on the S&P500 which began in March 2009 was still intact and would, in time break to a new all-time record high, above the high